Parshat Balak: Jewish, Zionist and Alone?

Leave a comment

Are the Jewish people destined to be isolated and demonized? Has having our own country only exacerbated Antisemitism and Anti-Zionism in the world? One verse in parshat Balak speaks directly to this issue: Can a particularistic Jewish identity coexist with a universalistic relationship with the world?

Bilaam, a non-Jewish prophet, is sent by Balak, king of Moab to curse the Jewish people. Yet, as the Talmud teaches, God turned his attempted curses into blessings. Bilaam, looking down on Bnei Yisrael, says they are “a people that dwells alone; not reckoned among the nations.” This hardly sounds like a blessing. In many ways it encapsulates the repeated struggle of the Jewish people throughout history to preserve their identity, resist assimilation and avoid persecution amongst the nations.

Most commentaries, however, regard this as a blessing for the Jewish people. Rashi teaches that it refers to the future when Israel will dwell safely in our land and not be punished like the other nations. The Malbim and Netziv, writing in Europe post-Enlightenment and amid experiences of Antisemitism, interpreted this verse within their historical context. When Jews are confident in their identity – they dwell in peace. When they assimilate – they are not worthy of being counted. Rabbi Jonathan Sacks provides a transformative reading of this verse: The blessing is for Jews to dwell “apart” – meaning our strength is in our distinctive experience and values. Yet, it is dangerous to remain alone. Through retaining our distinctiveness, we can and should have a positive impact on the other nations: “By being what only we are, we contribute to humanity what only we can give.”

Today, this verse also highlights the delicate balance Israel needs to maintain in the larger world. We need to work with our allies and take their concerns seriously and seek out those who wish to bless us. At the same time, we also need to remain strong and true to our identity and mission as the people of Israel. Shabbat Shalom -Karen Miller Jackson

Vayishlach: Embracing Our Name and Destiny

Leave a comment

A number of commentaries understand Yaacov’s encounter with an “ish”/angel in parshat Vayishlach to be the story of the struggles of the Jewish people with their enemies throughout history. According to this view, what can be learned from Yaacov and applied to the battle against today’s vehement strain of Antisemitism?

The idea that Yacov and Esav are not just individuals, but also the fathers of two nations, is already conveyed by God to Rivka when they are struggling inside her. The midrashic rabbis identify Esav or Edom with Rome and later commentaries with Christianity. Hence, when Yacov wrestles with the “ish,” this is interpreted by the midrash and Rashi to be the guardian angel (representative) of Esav. Many sources read this episode as foreshadowing the continual struggle between Judaism and Rome/Christianity and Yisrael. The Ramban writes that Yaacov’s strife with Esav is a “remez l’dorot” (hint to future generations) – an eternal conflict between the children of Yaacov (the Jewish nation) and the children of Esav (the Christian world) until Yaacov ultimately prevails. These perspectives are understandable given that many of the biblical interpreters lived in exile and suffered persecution or discrimination by the hand of their “Esav.” Today, with our own homeland and army, it may be time to add new perspectives and interpretation to this new stage of our story.

When the “ish” blesses Yaacov with his new name – Yisrael – this too becomes a source of resonance for the commentaries. Rashi writes that he is called Yisrael so that now he can face Esav and the world with noble leadership – “serara.” In contrast, the name Yaacov is connected to duplicity or concealment. Yaacov can only overcome the hate of Esav when he embraces his destiny as Yisrael: Forthright, strong, confident and proud in his identity. 

Today we are feeling the struggle, the sense of discord through the current face of Antisemitism and anti-Zionism. Yet today, with our own homeland, like Yaacov, we can draw on the strength and confidence to embrace and stand strong in who we are: Yisrael. Shabbat Shalom -Karen Miller Jackson