Vayigash: Achdut

Leave a comment

Vayigash is the parsha of achdut (Jewish unity). Before Oct. 7th we longed for more achdut. Since Oct. 7th we have been carried by the spirit of our people’s togetherness. Going forward, how do we preserve this achdut in Israeli society despite our differences? The approach of Yehuda toward Yosef provides some insight.

“Then Yehuda approached him [Yosef]…” This was a pivotal moment in the story of Yaacov’s sons. At their lowest point, the brothers could not speak peaceably with Yosef. Rashi characterizes their feelings of disdain as having “moved on from all feelings of brotherhood.” In parshat Vayigash, Yehuda (who doesn’t realize that he is speaking to his brother) speaks at length to Yosef, in the hopes of saving Binyamin as he had promised his father. 

Bereshit Rabbah likens this encounter to a well with good, cold water at the bottom, which is out of reach until someone ties rope to rope and draws from it and drinks. So too, Yehuda approached Yosef with many words until he found the ones which touched Yosef’s heart. The physical approach, along with words, communication, are the keys to bridging deep divides. 

The haftorah too, contains a vision for Jewish unity, particularly for modern Israel. Yechezkel is told by God to take two sticks and write on one the name Yosef (Ephraim and the tribes of Yisrael) and the other Yehuda and then, “Bring them close to each other, so that they become one stick.” Rav Avraham Yitzchak HaCohen Kook quoted this prophecy in his eulogy for Theodor Herzl and calls the secular Zionist movement the footsteps of the messiah son of Yosef. 

Rav Kook was a model for approaching and drawing closer to parts of Israeli society who thought and lived differently. How can we walk in the footsteps of Yehuda, Yechezkel and Rav Kook? By seeing what they all saw – we are one people. Shabbat Shalom -Karen Miller Jackson

Toldot: Truth vs. Deception

Leave a comment

What is meant by the verse in Micah, “Give truth to Jacob?” The commentaries discuss who is truthful and who is deceptive in parshat Toldot. This has particular significance for our world today, as we – the children of Yaacov – are fighting to get the truth out and dispel the deceptive lies about Israel. 

Yaacov is characterized by the Torah as “a plain (tam) man, dwelling in tents.” Rashi comments that Yaacov is the antithesis of his brother Esau who was regularly deceiving his father about his true character. This is surprising given that it is Yaacov who seems to act deceivingly. First, he makes a deal with Esau and receives the birthright (bechora) at a low moment for Esau, when he is exhausted. Next, Rivka instructs Yaakov to disguise himself as Esau so that Yitzchak blesses him and not Esau. When Yitzchak, who is going blind, asks Yaacov straight out who he is, he replies, “I am Esau, your firstborn.” Later, Yitzchak explicitly tells Esau that his brother “came in cunning (mirma) and took his blessing.” Yet, Rashi continues to defend Yaacov’s innocence. Rashi repunctuates one of the verses so that Yaacov is not technically lying: “I am [bringing you food], Esau is your firstborn,” and defines mirma as cleverness, not cunning.

Yet, other interpreters suggest that even if the blessing was meant for Yaacov, the means by which it was acquired led to consequences for Yaacov and his descendents – the Jewish people. In one midrash, Rachel deceives Yaacov on his wedding night with Leah to protect her sister’s dignity. She reminds him that he too deceived his father, measure for measure. Moreover, when Esau realizes what has happened and cries out “a great and bitter cry,” Bereshit Rabbah says that “Yaacov” was punished when Mordechai lets out a great, bitter cry in Shushan, due to Haman’s decree to wipe out the Jewish people. 

Yaacov was a man of truth. When he acted with duplicity it was to ensure the future of the Jewish people, yet there were long-term consequences. Today, as the world so easily consumes the lies of our enemies, we will continue to fight to “give truth to Yaacov,” to the Jewish people. Shabbat Shalom -Karen Miller Jackson

Lech Lecha 2023: Why Avraham?

Leave a comment

One of the major questions about parshat Lech Lecha is this: Why was Avraham chosen? We hear nothing about his faith or righteousness before this point. However, the biblical commentaries develop a fuller picture of Avraham’s moral clarity and spiritual strength, teaching us a valuable lesson about standing strong in our faith and devotion to Israel today.   

There are many descriptions from the midrash to Rambam about how Avraham discovered and embraced monotheism and became the father of the Jewish people. Midrash Bereshit Rabbah teaches: Avraham wandered from place to place and saw a palace in flames. He said, “how can it be that this palace has no leader?!” The owner of the castle (God) peered out and said, “I am the master of this palace (this world).” Here, Avraham’s faith came about through questioning, through not being able to make sense of the world. As Rabbi Sacks zt”l wrote: “What moved Abraham was not philosophical harmony but moral discord. For Abraham, faith began in cognitive dissonance. There is only one way of resolving this dissonance: by protesting evil and fighting it… It is as if God were saying to Abraham: I need you to help Me to put out the flames.”

Avraham’s distinctiveness may also be alluded to when he is later called “ha-ivri,” which means “the Hebrew” or “from the other side.” One midrashic opinion suggests a meaning which has resonated throughout Jewish history and again now: The entire world was on one side and he was on the other side [ever]. We will continue to speak our truth even when it goes against popular world opinion.

Perhaps the very reason God chose Avraham was because of his response to God’s call “Lech lecha…” Avraham answers the call fully even though it involves uncertainty and sacrifice. This too, is the story of the Jewish people and their love and commitment to Israel through the ages. 

Avraham models faith despite disorder and evil in the world, moral clarity even while in the minority and strength of commitment to the land of Israel – that is why he was chosen and inspires us to continue to hear the call of “Lech Lecha…” Shabbat Shalom -Karen Miller Jackson

Parshat Ekev: Attitude of Gratitude

Leave a comment

Parshat Ekev contains the source for one of the only biblically mandated blessings: Birkat Ha-mazon. The context and interpretation of this mitzvah contains a life lesson which goes beyond the realm of food. It is a reminder not to take basic things in life for granted and to view them as precious gifts.

Devarim 8 describes the treasures which await B’nei Yisrael when they enter the land of Israel. After encountering this bounty, the Torah urges: “And you shall eat, and be satisfied, and you shall bless Hashem for the good land he has given you.” This verse is ambiguous. “You shall eat and be satisfied” is clearly a prediction, but what about “and you shall bless Hashem”? Is it a prediction or a command? Shadal provides a psychological interpretation of the p’shat of this verse: At first this expression of thankfulness will happen naturally — it’s a prediction. However, over time it is human nature to forget the source of goodness and take gifts and success for granted. So in the following verse, the Torah commands us not to forget God for the gifts bestowed. The Ramban also says that the people would naturally appreciate the land of Israel and its produce after they enter it, while they still remember the hunger and challenges of obtaining food in Egypt and the desert. The Ramban then adds that Chazal viewed “and you shall thank Hashem” as a command, not a prediction. For both the Shadal and the Ramban, there are times when gratitude comes naturally, and there are times when we need to be commanded to appreciate.

The mitzvah of Birkat Ha-mazon applies in every generation to everyone. Why then do we bless Hashem for the land of Israel whether or not one lives in Israel? Just as Birkat Ha-mazon ensures we don’t take our physical food for granted, so too it ensures we don’t take Israel and its physical and spiritual gifts for granted, wherever we are in the world. Shabbat Shalom🍞🍇-Karen Miller Jackson

Parshat Shelach: Seeking Positive Zionism

Leave a comment

How is parshat Shelach a model for talking about Israel’s imperfections alongside positive Zionism in our world today? 

As the book of Bamidbar continues to describe Bnei Yisrael’s downward spiral of discontent in the desert, the spies are sent to scout out the land of Israel. Two words in this narrative highlight the depths of the spies’ mistake. Ten of the spies speak “dibbah,” or “libel” about the land of Israel. This negativity spreads among the nation, leading to punishment: that generation would die out in the desert. Rashi comments that “dibbah” refers to being an “influencer.” The spies influenced others to be negative as well. Moreover, the Ramban comments that the spies’ use of the word “efes” was their downfall, as it shut down the possibility of dialogue and conveyed that entering the land was impossible. Both words are indicative of language which shuts down constructive communication and spreads discontent. 

Yet, the parsha also contains seeds of optimism through the mitzvah of challah, the separating of the dough. This commandment originally only applied to Jews living in the land of Israel. However, Rambam teaches, based on rabbinic decree, that the mitzvah of challah should be observed by Jews anywhere in the world, so that it is not forgotten. Rashi, citing midrash Sifre, notes the Torah’s unique and urgent language used regarding mitzvat challah: “בְּבֹאֲכֶם” – “As you enter.” It applies even before settling the land. Perhaps this highlights how easy it is to take the land of Israel for granted. Fulfillment of challah is an expression of appreciation and optimism about Israel throughout Jewish history, whether one lives in Israel or the diaspora. 

The parsha’s language teaches that the mitzvah of challah provides an opportunity to make a tikun (correction) for the communication failures of the spies and to express our appreciation of and hopes for Israel. Shabbat Shalom -Karen Miller Jackson

Parshat Va’era: Personal and National Healing

Leave a comment

Parshat Va’era contains numerous requests for prayer and healing, surprisingly, from Pharaoh. During the plagues, Pharaoh asks Moshe to pray to God for him. The word which Pharoah repeatedly uses is ויעתר, “to entreat.” An exploration of the various uses of this word in Tanach provides a powerful message about prayer for healing and for current events in Israel.

The first occurrence of ויעתר, entreaty or petitioning of God, is when Yitzchak prays for a child. The Sages debate the deeper meaning of the word ויעתר. One interpretation: Yitzchak’s prayers become more frequent and urgent. Entreaty here means prayer in abundance. Pharaoh, however, does not pray himself, he entreats Moshe to pray. The midrash explains that Pharaoh was too full of pride and arrogance to have his prayers heard. Only Moshe’s pleadings on his behalf could be effective. From this we learn that haughtiness and intractability can block tefillot from being heard. In order to be able to petition God for mercy toward us, we need to be open to modifying our own frame of mind and foster compassion within ourselves. 

These examples are about prayer for individual healing. In Yirmiyahu, the root “עתר” is applied to the healing of the nation of Israel. Even amidst the destruction God promises, “I will heal them and reveal to them abundance (עתרת) of peace and truth.” The midrash learns from this that communal prayer – עתרת – is only heard when there is shalom amongst the people.

The past few weeks in Israel have been filled with genuine uncertainty and protests, alongside extreme and detrimental language, over proposed plans for judicial reforms. The biblical term for entreaty – עתר – provides a model for modern Israel: Effective change and national healing comes about by promoting peaceful debate with a dose of humility. Shabbat Shalom – Karen Miller Jackson 

*Israelis protest against Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government, in Tel Aviv, on January 14, 2023. (Jack Guez/AFP) From Times of Israel https://www.timesofisrael.com/some-80000-rally-in-tel-aviv-against-governments-sweeping-judicial-overhaul/